Tua Tagovailoa shouldn’t be in the field Thursday night. Loopholes in the collective bargaining agreement between the NFL and the players union allowed the Miami Dolphins medical team to clear it up and create the frightening situation that happened to the entire nation.
“The problem isn’t necessarily that protocol wasn’t followed,” said Miami attorney Brad Son, a candidate with some players backing to become the next NFL CEO. “They have these toothless bases and nobody holds them accountable. The Federation and the Palestinian Authority codified a protocol with loopholes big enough to drive a truck through.”
The central question – and why the union is promptly investigating a possible breach of protocol – is why Tagoviloa was cleared mid-game from the previous Sunday’s concussion protocol during the win over the Buffalo Bills.
The quarterback hit the lawn after taking a hit from the Bells defender. Tagoviloa immediately raised his hands towards his head, the fingers of his left hand looking a bit strange.
Then he stood and tried to get rid of him, stumbled and lost his balance and tied his knees under him. His teammates had to carry him to his feet until the coaches came out.
Tagovailoa was taken to the locker room and declared it doubtful he would come back with a “headshot”. But he later returned to the match, and the team explained that he had injuries to his “back” and “ankle”.
“Ninety-nine percent of physicians who don’t work with the team see that you just shed cobwebs, sway, have to hang, and that player never comes back,” neuroscientist Chris Nowinsky, PhD, founder and CEO of the Concussion Legacy Foundation, told The Daily Saturday News.
So how could he have been brought back into the game, especially with an unaffiliated trauma consultant (UNC) involved?
Well, the NFL Concussion Game Checklist says in nitty-gritty that ‘gross players’ gross kinetic instability’ is determined by [the] The team physician, in consultation with UNC, to be a neurological cause.”
In other words, Son said, “The team doctor can find out that the injury was not caused by a nerve, and it was the player’s knee and not the head, and the independent neurologist no longer needed to consult him. And the PA agreed.”
In fact, the full CBA language states that “the decision to return a player to participation remains within the professional judgment of the lead team physician or the team physician assigned to assess and treat concussion, which is made in accordance with these protocols.” And all decisions involved in return only need to be “confirmed” by an independent neurologist.
We hope the investigation will reveal the facts about how this decision was made. The NFL’s chief medical officer, Dr. Allen Sales, promised to release all results to the public.
But when Executive Vice President of NFL Communications Jeff Miller said Wednesday that “every indication from our point of view is that… [the protocol] ‘, unaffiliated professionals weren’t buying it.
“It was a series of bad choices that just hit the brain,” Nowinsky said. “I can accept if last Sunday was a mistake in the game. But pretending it wasn’t a mistake, the rest of the week is showing a ruthlessness with the player’s health I feel like I haven’t seen her in a while.”
“Sometimes a cover-up is worse than a crime,” Nowinsky added. “But I feel the crime is really bad and the coverage is getting worse.”
The truth is, Tagovailoa showed no fewer than three “potential signs of concussion,” as defined by the CBA, after hitting the bills:
1. Slowness in getting up after a head injury (“hit to the head” may involve secondary contact with the playing surface)
2. Motor coordination/balance problems (stuttering, tripping/falling, slow/uphill movement)
3. Hold the head after contact
If Tagovailoa’s left hand indicated upon review that he was also in a short “fence” position, that would make him four potential concussions. “Difficulty with balance or coordination” is also listed as “a possible concussion symptom”.
The difference between signs and symptoms are signs that you can notice with your eyes, and symptoms are what the player reports to doctors or tests reveal.
Dolphins QB required auditions before being allowed to return to the Bills game, according to Sales, and subsequently auditioned over the course of the week. But Nowinsky said the league’s preference for backroom testing is also part of the problem.
“This is a tactic the NFL has used for years,” he said. The NFL is attempting a concussion assessment around the locker room protocol or blue tent protocol. And what beats these things is the field signals. But the NFL doesn’t want that because they want plenty of wiggle room. “He got up and passed the concussion test that’s known to be completely inaccurate.”
Tagovailoa is back in action after undoubtedly showing those signs and it was a terrible symptom. Fortunately, John Harbo, head coach of the Baltimore Ravens, stood up and attacked the dolphins on Friday to make it clear that people in the clear area don’t think that’s a good thing.
Like most people probably, I couldn’t believe what I saw [Thursday] night. “I couldn’t believe what I saw last Sunday,” Harbow said. “It was just something that was amazing to see. I’ve been coaching for nearly 40 years in college and the NFL, and I’ve never seen anything like it before.”
Harbo said the crows are being very careful. Two weeks ago, wide receiver Devin Duvernay had no symptoms at all, but Baltimore put him off for the next game and most of the week’s practice.
“I appreciate our documents,” he said. “I think they might call themselves conservative, but that’s what they should be. The other part of it, [Thursday] Night, it wasn’t something you wanted to see.”
The Giants deal with Tagoviloa’s Alabama teammate in 2019, Evan Neale told The News he stopped the Dolphins-Bengals game after seeing Tagoviloa go into a “dueling” position with his hands in front of his face and fingers crossed.
“I can’t watch it anymore,” Neil said. “It was hard to see him in a carriage like that. It was scary. At first I thought he broke his fingers or something. But I watched the play more and saw that he hit his head. That’s scary. Fortunately, he’s responsive, he’s conscious, he can move his limbs.” “.
Giants coach Brian Dabol, Alabama’s 2017 Tagovailoa offensive coordinator, started to rip on Friday when asked about Dolphins QB.
“It means a lot to me,” Daboll said. “It was hard… I don’t really think of them as players. They are not very far from my children. [in age]. “
Recently retired NFLPA president JC Tretter said players were “angry” and “frightened for the safety of one of our brothers” after seeing a player removed from protocol despite clearly displaying “no-go” symptoms.
Like Sohn, Tretter called for the protocols to be modified, not just to review this case.
“Until we have an objective and reliable method for diagnosing brain injury, we must do everything we can, including modifying protocols, to reduce the potential for human error,” Tritter wrote. “Failure in medical judgment is failure of protocols when it comes to the well-being of our players.”
Unfortunately, the federation is part of the problem because there are not enough checks and balances to protect players in the CBA that the federation is signed to.
The sad truth for the players is that they are also afraid of a concussion diagnosis because it stigmatizes them, Nowinski said in the Federation defence. Many players ended their careers because teams deemed them untouchable due to their history of concussions.
“It can be worse to go out when you are healthy than to play when you have a concussion,” Nowinski said of the mindset unfortunately adopted by many players fighting for jobs.
Sohn summed up the need for reform this way: “There are a lot of short-term interests that run the risk of taking priority over health. Tua is probably a tough kid who wants to go out and play football. But you need cops from making bad decisions in the short term. The same goes with the team doctor. The same goes for the league.”
()
from San Jose News Bulletin https://sjnewsbulletin.com/the-nfl-players-guild-dolphin-medical-staff-all-failed-at-miami-tagovailoa-the-mercury-news/
No comments:
Post a Comment